O'Toole's Reviews - Ratings and Testimonials of O'Toole's Restaurant Pub in Albany, NY

Customer Testimonials

Check out what others have to say about O’Toole’s…or leave a review yourself. Let us know how your experience with O’Toole’s was and drop a photo if you’ve got one to share!


Last night Our family decided

Last night Our family decided to go to O’toole’s party of like 25 after a service and The hostess right to manger to find accommodations for us
We got the back room plenty of space and Our waitress ( I wish I caught her name )did an Amazing job waiting on Us
This wasn’t my first time but most of the family it was and they seemed to like it
The food came out within a good time after ordering seemed we all enjoyed what we ordered
Thank you All again for the great service and making our ending of the day Enjoyable .
Thanks again


Fish dinner

Well 2 months ago we ordered 2 fish and chips dinners for take out. Well it was not good. Fish was very dry. I wrote a review complaining about it. Management responded and offered to make it right with 2 fish dinner on them. We went back tonight and it was delicious. It was moist and very tasty. Maybe fish dinners are fresher Friday then Wednesday. Our server Micayla L was extremely attentive and very pleasant.
Thank you O’toole’s

Donald Mesick

St Patrick’s

Julia Baker

Excellent food, service and atmosphere.Great

Excellent food, service and atmosphere.
Great experience.

The Rose Dental Team

Best Night of the week.

5 of us stopped by this past Weds night. We wanted to try somewhere new but nobody had any suggestions, so we went to O’tools, an old favorite of ours.
The chicken quesadillas (sp?) were the Weds night special ($10.95) and everyone jumped on it. And all were delighted, the beans and rice were a meal by there selves. Onions were perfect, big, big serving size. Chicken had great flavor. It’s a fun and interesting meal, that smells as good as it taste. I’m old so I think I’m a comedian, and the waitress handled me politely. She was terrific, I probably didn’t tip enough. I have had this same meal maybe 10 times in the past. It has never been as good as it is now… congrats on staying strong and getting better during this hard time…I’ll be back.

Bill Giering

Amazing Service with a smile!!!!!

First time at Otooles and I had the pleasure of having Brittany as my server and let me tell you she does a wonderful job. From the second I sat down to the minute I left she was the definition of accommodation. Food was excellent and the atmosphere is just spectacular. I would recommend this place to everyone

Michael Angerami

Some more Vegetarian selections for

Some more Vegetarian selections for Lunch & Dinner would be good



I recently booked the back room for my daughter’s baby shower. It was Absolutely wonderful the room was great the food was delicious and the service was excellent.
All the Guest were very pleased. A special thank you to Anthony and Valerie, and to all the wait staff, they were very courteous and kept on top of things filling the buffet and clearing the tables. Thanks for making it special!

Dorothy Kevlin

Gluten free buffet

I’m hoping you do another gluten free night. Never seen my daughter so happy. In the last 3 yrs she hasn’t been able to go anywhere and just pig out with so many options. And staff was all so welcoming and informative.


Irish Nachis

The Irish Nachos are the best please bring them back to the menu!

Brooke Smith

Wonderful Backroom Party

Last week, my husband and I had a gathering of about 35 people to celebrate our son’s recent engagement. We had heard good things about the menu and decided to give it a shot. We were not disappointed! The room is very new and styled beautifully with leather couches and a large stone fireplace. There was a nice sized bar in the room and a large screen TV. There were many items on the menu, and we chose chicken parmesan, penne, sliced steak, garlic mashed potatoes, etc. All dishes were delicious. Our guests all commented on the tasty food . The banquet staff was very helpful and did a very nice job of keeping the food pans full and warm. I would highly recommend this venue for any kind of gathering. I think they can hold up to 75 or so. We will definitely use them again.

JoAnn Strube

Great Service.

Hands down the best server I have had the pleasure of meeting. Very polite and professional. Our order was taken quickly and our food was great.


Great Food an Staff

Great Food an Staff


Tuesday Burgers!

I stopped in this past Tuesday to order my burger, being they’re on special on Tuesdays. I’ve always loved their burgers, taste like they were grilled outside. I’ll have to stop in more often. I’ve never been disappointed with the burgers. Give them a try, you won’t be disappointed.

Cheryl A.